"How much does a turntable cost these days?"
Someone (who is not an audiophile) recently asked me that question. And, like usual, it was a struggle answering it, because of all the variables involved. Are we talking new? Used? (If used, how old?) What are the quality expectations? And so on.
In this case, I mumbled something along the lines of "about $450, for a Rega RP-1." For whatever reason, the RP-1 came to mind first, although there are a lot of selling points. It has decent sound, seems to be well made (and might last 20+ years like older Rega Planar 2 turntables), but has a price that's not too horrifying for the non-audiophile.
But...perhaps I went too high. Maybe the right answer is $330 for a Denon DP-300F.
Indeed, the $330 Denon has two huge selling points for the first time buyer. (These are the people most likely to ask "how much?") It's $330 vs. $450. One thing I've noticed with people in the real world: they like their audio equipment cheap. For example, many audiophiles will see a $2,000 phono cartridge, and light up like a Christmas tree. "Wow! I bet that would sound great playing my audiophile 45 RPM records!!!!" Meanwhile, a "normal person" will shudder. "$2,000? For a needle? I bought my last system for 10% of that!!!!"
The Denon also has the selling point of convenience. It has full automation. Hit a button and it starts playing. Hit a button and it stops. It also stops when it reaches the end of the record. Just like a CD player, except the discs are bigger. Convenience is always a selling point for non-audiophiles.
The convenience has even interested some audiophiles. I've read of many people who've bought one as a second turntable. Perhaps a bedroom system, where the auto-shutoff is handy if one falls asleep while listening to the gentle sawing of strings. But the Denon is always a second turntable. The main turntable remains the Linn LP12/VPI/whatever.
The Denon also has an advantage of some upgradibilty. The cartridge can be replaced. The built-in phono stage can be bypassed to use an external phono amp. Thus one can get started for $330, and, as funds allow, make upgrades.
I had sort of assumed the Denon might "only" be good as a second turntable. But recently, I've had a chance to hear the Denon, and even hear it some good systems. (It was one source used with Quad ESL-57 speakers that I heard a while back.) And I've been impressed. It's hard to gauge exact sound quality - I've only heard it in "other" systems, and with unfamiliar LPs. That said, what I hear suggests that many will find this turntable perfectly fine. It certainly would suit many first time buyers, and be revelation to those using a junky "plastic deck" turntable.
I also think more seasoned audiophiles might be happy. Someone who mostly uses digital, but still has a few old LPs, might be perfectly happy. And I think I could use this turntable as my primary turntable, and live to tell the tale.
Of course, the Denon has its limits. I think the Rega RP-1 would be a huge step up. But that comes at a cost of more than $100 extra, and the loss of the automation. The Denon also has a "plastic" feel, and between that, and the added complexity of the automation, I would doubt the Denon would be a 20+ year investment. (Unless used lightly.) But, while there are limits, it's worth remembering that this is a $330 turntable.
I was talking to someone recently about the Denon. He actually owns one. Like me, he has heard a lot of good turntables the last year or so. He can hear the difference between the Denon and a $2,000 Rega. And yet, he's happy with the Denon. Happy enough that when I saw him he was looking for used records to buy. Which shows the turntable is doing something right. In the end, what matters is not the detail, bass, or even suppressing surface noise as much as possible. What matters is doing a good enough job of playing music that you will actually use the turntable to play records.
Edited 1/23/18 to remove dead link.
Appreciation of good audio equipment doesn't have to stop even if an audiophile lives in a mobile home.
Sunday, January 17, 2016
Friday, December 25, 2015
Christmas gift cartridge
It is Christmas Day, and one thing that wasn't under my tree this morning was a phono cartridge. It would admittedly be hard for there to be a phono cartridge under my tree, because there is no tree. This year is one of those "Why bother? Bah humbug!" years. But I digress.
I had given serious thought to getting a cartridge as a "to me, from me" Christmas gift. Part of this, I suppose, was just to give myself something other than my usual box of nothing. Beyond that, though, a part of me keeps thinking it would be nice to have a new cartridge. A budget cartridge, of course. I am The Mobile Home Audiophile, after all, not The Stately European Castle Audiophile.
Indeed, I had a vision of going really budget: $50 or less. I have never had such a cheap cartridge. But I've been intrigued by forum talk about cheap cartridges that perform much, much better than they have any right to. For example, a lot of virtual ink has been spilled on forums praising the Audio-Technica AT95e.
Past that, a cheap cartridge has some practical value. You can play it for hours for less critical listening and not care about the stylus getting worn. You can use it on questionable records, too, without worry. The stylus gets destroyed, well, it's not as heartbreaking as it would be if a Koetsu were killed. And some cheap cartridges said to work well for playing severely worn records - some people keep a cheap conical stylus cartridge around just for that reason alone.
So I decided to get a cheap cartridge. Visions of fun budget cartridges danced in my head...until practical reality set in.
The main practical reality is that a lot of the budget choices are only available by mail order. Local dealers tend to limit the ranges - it's not possible to carry everything. Furthermore, some dealers wouldn't touch a $50 cartridge even with a 10 foot tonearm.
Furthermore, some of the more interesting cartridges that get discussed are mail order, period. LP Gear, for example, has some interesting cartridges based around the AT95e. They seem to use the AT95e body, but improved, custom styli. Nagaoka gets lots of praise, but appears to be only available by mail in the US. And so on.
Mail order is not necessarily a deal breaker. I prefer shopping locally. But I'm also a realist, and realize that there are times this isn't viable. A local dealer probably does not have the sales to support sourcing custom styli for cheap cartridges. A local dealer also probably doesn't have the resources to stock every available cartridge. It makes far more sense to have a selection that the dealer knows well, and that will work fine for most buyers.
But mail order brings two problems. First, one has to rely 100% on Internet talk for making a decision. Even with that talk, there is a real risk of not liking the cartridge. One can sell it, but let's face it: a used budget cartridge is about as salable as a used toothbrush. While I guess losing $50 isn't the end of the world, I am frugal and hate buying anything that disappoints.
Problem #2: I don't like installing cartridges. No, actually I hate it. How much I hate it depends on the cartridge design. I am not particularly good, and I don't have the top tools. I have only the Technics overhang gauge, and a paper protractor. This protractor is one of those where you align the cantilever (ideally) or cartridge body (less ideal, but easier) so it's parallel to the lines printed at Point A. Then, you move to Point B. And possibly keep going between Point A and Point B until either the cartridge is spot-on, or you ready to move yourself to Point C: the booby hatch.
It is very tempting to just have this hypothetical cartridge installed by someone else. My local dealer could do it, and do a better job than I could. Of course, there would be a service charge. And so suddenly the cheap cartridge isn't so cheap anymore. It might run, say, $100 between purchase and installation charges. This raises the question if it wouldn't be better to buy a more expensive cartridge locally that would include free installation.
Yes. It would appear the more expensive cartridge would be a better. And so...the dreams of that $50 or less cartridge fell faster than a BSR record changer tossed out a 5th story window.
I had given serious thought to getting a cartridge as a "to me, from me" Christmas gift. Part of this, I suppose, was just to give myself something other than my usual box of nothing. Beyond that, though, a part of me keeps thinking it would be nice to have a new cartridge. A budget cartridge, of course. I am The Mobile Home Audiophile, after all, not The Stately European Castle Audiophile.
Indeed, I had a vision of going really budget: $50 or less. I have never had such a cheap cartridge. But I've been intrigued by forum talk about cheap cartridges that perform much, much better than they have any right to. For example, a lot of virtual ink has been spilled on forums praising the Audio-Technica AT95e.
Past that, a cheap cartridge has some practical value. You can play it for hours for less critical listening and not care about the stylus getting worn. You can use it on questionable records, too, without worry. The stylus gets destroyed, well, it's not as heartbreaking as it would be if a Koetsu were killed. And some cheap cartridges said to work well for playing severely worn records - some people keep a cheap conical stylus cartridge around just for that reason alone.
So I decided to get a cheap cartridge. Visions of fun budget cartridges danced in my head...until practical reality set in.
The main practical reality is that a lot of the budget choices are only available by mail order. Local dealers tend to limit the ranges - it's not possible to carry everything. Furthermore, some dealers wouldn't touch a $50 cartridge even with a 10 foot tonearm.
Furthermore, some of the more interesting cartridges that get discussed are mail order, period. LP Gear, for example, has some interesting cartridges based around the AT95e. They seem to use the AT95e body, but improved, custom styli. Nagaoka gets lots of praise, but appears to be only available by mail in the US. And so on.
Mail order is not necessarily a deal breaker. I prefer shopping locally. But I'm also a realist, and realize that there are times this isn't viable. A local dealer probably does not have the sales to support sourcing custom styli for cheap cartridges. A local dealer also probably doesn't have the resources to stock every available cartridge. It makes far more sense to have a selection that the dealer knows well, and that will work fine for most buyers.
But mail order brings two problems. First, one has to rely 100% on Internet talk for making a decision. Even with that talk, there is a real risk of not liking the cartridge. One can sell it, but let's face it: a used budget cartridge is about as salable as a used toothbrush. While I guess losing $50 isn't the end of the world, I am frugal and hate buying anything that disappoints.
Problem #2: I don't like installing cartridges. No, actually I hate it. How much I hate it depends on the cartridge design. I am not particularly good, and I don't have the top tools. I have only the Technics overhang gauge, and a paper protractor. This protractor is one of those where you align the cantilever (ideally) or cartridge body (less ideal, but easier) so it's parallel to the lines printed at Point A. Then, you move to Point B. And possibly keep going between Point A and Point B until either the cartridge is spot-on, or you ready to move yourself to Point C: the booby hatch.
It is very tempting to just have this hypothetical cartridge installed by someone else. My local dealer could do it, and do a better job than I could. Of course, there would be a service charge. And so suddenly the cheap cartridge isn't so cheap anymore. It might run, say, $100 between purchase and installation charges. This raises the question if it wouldn't be better to buy a more expensive cartridge locally that would include free installation.
Yes. It would appear the more expensive cartridge would be a better. And so...the dreams of that $50 or less cartridge fell faster than a BSR record changer tossed out a 5th story window.
Friday, November 27, 2015
Black Friday
Today is Black Friday. A traditional start for the Christmas shopping season here in the United States. This is a day that has become something else over the years. Stores open at insane times. 6 AM? 3 AM? Anything is possible, including stores that open on Thanksgiving and stay open all night long! And it seems like every year some ugly incident occurs at some store. Someone gets maimed so badly by the crowd charging in to find That Great Bargain that he or she ends up hospitalized. Or even dead.
I'm not the first to note this, but there is a certain hypocrisy in all this. On Thursday, we give thanks for what we have. Hours later, some of us are in a store fighting to the death over a flatscreen TV set.
It's my plan to avoid shopping today, unless I need to make a quick stop by the grocery store. (Interestingly, a clerk once told me that his grocery store was dead on Black Friday. Apparently, people are too busy with the mall to do anything like shopping for mere food.)
The Black Friday shopping orgy at the mall is just not my thing.
I'm not interested in "hot door buster" deals. (Usually, if one reads the fine print, there is something like two per store, which are probably snagged within twelve seconds of the store opening at Insane O'Clock.)
Every year, I get less and less interested in the hot item of the year, which is often some short lived "investment." Today's hot toy, tomorrow's Goodwill find.
These days, when I give gifts, I try to use something other than a one day sale. I try to use my intelligence, and creativity, to come up with something right for the recipient.
And when doing any shopping, I always prefer dealing with stores that have reasonable prices, and a willingness to give the best deal they can year round. I prefer buying something that will be in use much longer than it takes to pay the next month's credit card bill. I like buying stuff, in fact, that will last a long time. And I like dealing with stores that view me as a person, not a "consumer" whose sole value is what I spend. I also like shopping with small stores that are locally based, because more money stays local, and helps the place where I live.
All this - and more - is what one can get at a good audio dealer. Admittedly good dealers can be hard to find. But they are out there.
I'm not the first to note this, but there is a certain hypocrisy in all this. On Thursday, we give thanks for what we have. Hours later, some of us are in a store fighting to the death over a flatscreen TV set.
It's my plan to avoid shopping today, unless I need to make a quick stop by the grocery store. (Interestingly, a clerk once told me that his grocery store was dead on Black Friday. Apparently, people are too busy with the mall to do anything like shopping for mere food.)
The Black Friday shopping orgy at the mall is just not my thing.
I'm not interested in "hot door buster" deals. (Usually, if one reads the fine print, there is something like two per store, which are probably snagged within twelve seconds of the store opening at Insane O'Clock.)
Every year, I get less and less interested in the hot item of the year, which is often some short lived "investment." Today's hot toy, tomorrow's Goodwill find.
These days, when I give gifts, I try to use something other than a one day sale. I try to use my intelligence, and creativity, to come up with something right for the recipient.
And when doing any shopping, I always prefer dealing with stores that have reasonable prices, and a willingness to give the best deal they can year round. I prefer buying something that will be in use much longer than it takes to pay the next month's credit card bill. I like buying stuff, in fact, that will last a long time. And I like dealing with stores that view me as a person, not a "consumer" whose sole value is what I spend. I also like shopping with small stores that are locally based, because more money stays local, and helps the place where I live.
All this - and more - is what one can get at a good audio dealer. Admittedly good dealers can be hard to find. But they are out there.
Thursday, November 26, 2015
Thanksgiving
Today is Thanksiving in the United States. A day when we give thanks for life's blessings, such as family, friends, good health, and so on. These truly are blessings to be thankful for.
Since this is an audiophile blog, I'd also like to express gratitude for audio equipment, which can be an incredible gift.
With audio equipment, we have the ability to hear what we want when we want. One wants a Mozart symphony at 3 AM? Not a problem. There's no need to leave the house. There's no need to wait until the next time the local symphony plays Mozart. Just drop the LP on the turntable, the CD into the CD player, or make a selection on Spotify.
Audio equipment gives us the ability to hear works we might not ever hear otherwise.
We also have the ability to hear performers we couldn't hear otherwise. There are countless great musicians who are no longer living, and yet they live on through recordings. Some musicians are still alive and performing, but have changed over the years, and so recordings again come to the rescue, allowing us to hear what they were like years ago.
So now let us pause, and be thankful for the amazing gift of recorded music, and for the contributions of all who made it happen.
Thank you!
Since this is an audiophile blog, I'd also like to express gratitude for audio equipment, which can be an incredible gift.
With audio equipment, we have the ability to hear what we want when we want. One wants a Mozart symphony at 3 AM? Not a problem. There's no need to leave the house. There's no need to wait until the next time the local symphony plays Mozart. Just drop the LP on the turntable, the CD into the CD player, or make a selection on Spotify.
Audio equipment gives us the ability to hear works we might not ever hear otherwise.
We also have the ability to hear performers we couldn't hear otherwise. There are countless great musicians who are no longer living, and yet they live on through recordings. Some musicians are still alive and performing, but have changed over the years, and so recordings again come to the rescue, allowing us to hear what they were like years ago.
So now let us pause, and be thankful for the amazing gift of recorded music, and for the contributions of all who made it happen.
Thank you!
Thursday, October 22, 2015
Remembering my old Newcomb phonograph
A "Throwback Thursday" memoir.
When I was growing up, my mother and I often visited thrift shops. You never knew what great treasure might turn up, priced at next-to-zero. (A sad commentary about our throwaway society: today's expensive item is tomorrow's $1 find at the thrift shop!) One very memorable treasure I found was an old Newcomb phonograph.
The Newcomb might well have been an old school phonograph. Certainly, I remembered seeing many Newcomb phonographs at school. A Newcomb phonograph with a brown case was standard equipment on the back counters of my elementary school classes, and they were a common sight in junior high and high school. But the one I found was far older than any I'd seen before - it probably dated to the monophonic LP era, and it had a tube amp.
The tube amp was probably the selling point. I liked tubes! They seemed so neat in an old technology way. (I now wonder about my love of modern audiophile tube amps. How much of it is sound quality? How much are secondary issues, such as liking the glow of tubes?) Needless to say, the phonograph "followed me home" that day.
There was, however, one small, itsy-bitsy problem. The phonograph was equipped with a cartridge that could not play anything newer than a mono LP. (Stereo cartridges can play mono LPs, but a mono era cartridge will totally destroy a stereo LP.)
So...I knew I needed a mono LP. Fortunately, as I dug through my record rack, I found I had one. Beethoven's Fifth Symphony, which had come from a used book sale. Today, I have no idea why I bought it. This was before I listened to classical repertoire - apart from a Hooked on Classics record. Indeed, as far as I can recall, I had not listened to that record, not even for a second, since buying it. But that day I was happy I had it - it was something I could play on my new-to-me phonograph!
I powered up the phonograph, and let the tubes warm up. (Back then, I was totally unaware of old electronics safety, including the thought that you don't just plug in something and turn it on. It may be a miracle I never burned our house down.) Once the phonograph amp was warm, I started the record.
And, at some point, I got hooked. I mean really hooked. While normal kids my age were playing some rock recording, in stereo, with the volume set to rattle the windows of the house across the street, I'd be playing my Beethoven record at fairly moderate volume. And so the phono gave me one gift: my first real, extended, enjoyable experience listening to classical repertoire.
In time, something went wrong, and the phonograph refused to turn on one day.
After that phono stopped working, I lost interest in the Beethoven record. I did make a couple of attempts to make cassette copies on newer stereo systems. (Back then, like many kids of the 80s, I'd typically play a record only to make a tape copy. Indeed, one big shock I gave my mother was when I told her that when I got my first good turntable, I'd actually play records. For real. No cassette copies.)
But I never really liked listening to the cassette copies. I never really felt like playing the record itself, either.
I don't know if I questioned this back then. Why did a favorite record suddenly end up collecting dust? I might have said that I'd probably just listened to it too many times, and lost interest. This is certainly possible.
But today I wonder if there also isn't another answer. Perhaps that old phonograph performed better than either modern system I had access to in the late 1980s.
Many would, of course, find this thought laughable. An old school phonograph (with who knows how many hours on the tubes?!) is better than a fairly new mass market stereo system?
And to be sure, this phonograph was not an audiophile product. It also would seem hopeless to the average mass market system buyer. It wasn't stereo. It didn't have 100 watts of output power. It didn't have big speakers. It didn't -
No, it didn't have a lot of that. But somehow it managed to communicate something important on that record. And it did a better job of communicating that than either modern system.
I now vaguely recall something else. I tried other classical works on the modern stereo systems. I found some things that interested me, but I seem to recall it was harder listening. It was harder getting interested in the works.
That school phonograph helped teach me an important lesson, although I didn't understand it until years later. The lesson is that a lot of technical and performance issues so important in the audio industry are really secondary issues. You can have the best transparency and stereo imaging in the world. You can have massive amounts of power. You can have many technical features that have been marketed to death over the years. But if the system doesn't convey the musical soul of the performance, then it's really no better than a cheap transistor radio at KMart.
Edited 10/23/15 and 11/7/15. Editing was minor, mostly for clarity in the last paragraph.
Edited 10/23/15 and 11/7/15. Editing was minor, mostly for clarity in the last paragraph.
Labels:
#tbt,
Beethoven,
mono,
monophonic,
newcomb,
thrift stores
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)